Skip to content
Login
/
Join
/
Search
0 /
$0.00
Cart
Facebook
Instagram
Home
Toys & Novelties
Active
Bath
Brainteaser
Candy
Construction
Decor
Dolls
Educational
Fidget/Sensory Toys
Infant & Toddler
Lego
Music
Novelties
Outdoor Toys
Planes, Trains & Automobiles
Plush
Pretend
Puppets
Puzzles
Science
Stickers
Tattoos
3D Prints
Games
All Games
Kids Games
Family Games
Strategy Games
Cooperative Games
Party Games
Escape Room & Mystery Games
Card Games
Dice Games
1 Player Games
2 Player Games
Game Accessories
Games ON SALE
Top Game Picks
Top Strategy Games
Top 2-Player Games
Top Kids Games
Top Party Games
Top Fighting Games
Top Cooperative Games
Top Card Games
Toy Soup Must Haves!
The Unmatched Collection
Puzzles
All Puzzles
Cobble Hill
Ravensburger
Eurographics
Pomegranate
Laurence King
White Mountain
Wooden Adult Puzzles
Heye
Wasgij!
Mystery Puzzles
Family Puzzles
Tray Puzzles
Wooden Children's Puzzles
Floor Puzzles
39 pc and less
40 to 99 pc
100 to 199 pc
200 pc
275 to 300 pc
500 to 750 pc
1000 pc
1500 pc
2000 pc
3000+ pc
Puzzle Accessories
Crafts
All Crafts
Paint by Numbers
DIY and Hobby Kits
Colouring Books
Stickers & Sticker Books
Tutti Frutti "Play Dough"
Craft Supplies
Crayola
Books
All Books
Activity Books
Board Books
Chapter Books
Educational Books
Picture Books
Bookmarks
Pretty Things
Collectables
Lorcana
Palm Pals
Pokemon
Schleich Miniatures
Siku Die Cast Vehicles
Squishables
Squishmallows
Price
Under $5
$5 to $10
$10 to $20
$20 to $50
$50 and up
Vendor
Asobu
Aurora
B4 Adventure
Blue Orange
Brio
Cobble Hill
Crazy Aaron's
Crayola
Crocodile Creek
Days of Wonder
Douglas
Educational Insights
eeBoo
Eurographics
Faber-Castell
Fat Brain Toys
Folkmanis Puppets
Gamewright/Ceaco
Geospace
Great Pretenders
HABA
Hanayama
Hape
Higgins Brothers
Janod
Kikkerland
Kinsmart
Klutz
Learning Resources
LEGO
All LEGO Sets
Lego For Adults
City
Classic
Creator
Duplo
Friends
Harry Potter
Licensed
Minecraft
Speed Champions
Star Wars
Technic
LEGO Books
Loz Blocks
Make Believe Ideas
Manhattan Toy
Mattel
Meccano
MindWare
National Geographic
Ooly
Outset Media
Peaceable Kingdom
Peter Pauper Press
Pico
Playmobil
All Playmobil
Playmobil 123
City Life / Family Fun
City Action / Vehicles
Country
Fantasy
Licensed
Pirates & Knights
Playmonster
Plus-Plus
Pokemon
Pomegranate
Ravensburger
Rubik's
Rustik
Schleich
All Schleich
Dinosaurs
Farm
Horses
Pets
Wild Life
Scholastic
Schylling
Set Enterprises
Siku
Studiostone Creative
Squishables
TENZI
Thames & Kosmos
ThinkFun
Tutti Frutti
The Unemployed Philosophers Guild
University Games
Waboba
Winning Moves
Age
Ages 0 to 2
Ages 2 and up
Ages 3 and up
Ages 4 and up
Ages 5 and up
Ages 6 and up
Ages 7 and up
Ages 8 and up
Ages 9 and up
Ages 10 and up
Age 11 and up
Ages 12 and up
Ages 14 and up
Specials
Cards
Mystery Puzzles
24 results
Sort by:
Featured
Best Selling
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Quick
shop
Murder Mystery Case File Puzzle: Passport to Murder
$31.99
Quick
shop
Alfred Hitchcock Pz1000
$24.99
Quick
shop
Murder on the Hindenburg Mystery Puzzle Pz1000
$24.99
Quick
shop
Stolen Time Mystery Puzzle Pz264
$27.99
Quick
shop
The Lost Fire Mystery Puzzle Pz264
$27.99
Quick
shop
A Murderous Birthday Mystery Puzzle Pz408
$35.99
Quick
shop
The Gift of Murder Mystery Puzzle Pz408
$35.99
Quick
shop
WASGIJ Destiny #6 Child's Play!
$28.99
Quick
shop
WASGIJ Retro #7 Rock Around The Clock
$28.99
Quick
shop
WASGIJ Mystery #26 Date Night
$28.99
Quick
shop
WASGIJ Mystery #25 Eurosound Contest!
$29.99
Quick
shop
WASGIJ Destiny #26 Organic Overload
$28.99
Quick
shop
WASGIJ Original #45: Moving Day
$28.99
Quick
shop
WASGIJ Original #43 Aquarium Antics!
$29.99
Quick
shop
WASGIJ Mystery #23 Pooch Parlour!
$29.99
Quick
shop
WASGIJ Original #6 Blooming Marvellous!
$28.99
Quick
shop
WASGIJ Mystery #27 A Close Shave
$28.99
Quick
shop
Wasgij Destiny #28 Dad Cave
$29.99
Quick
shop
WASGIJj Advent Calendar 24x54pc
$39.99
Quick
shop
Istanbul Express Mystery Puzzle Pz1000
$24.99
Quick
shop
Murder by the Pyramids Mystery Puzzle Pz1000
$24.99
Quick
shop
Murder on the Titanic Pz1000
$24.99
Quick
shop
Sherlock Holmes & The Speckled Band Pz1000
$24.99
Quick
shop
Grounds for Murder 1000 pc
$24.99
Left
Continue shopping
Your Order
You have no items in your cart
